Fair and Practical Ways to Assess Students Online

online assessment methods

Worried your online tests will be unfair or easy to cheat on? The best online assessment methods match what you teach, give students practice first, and reward real thinking. Start from your learning goal, then pick the format.

This guide sits within the wider series on online teaching basics and focuses on checking learning fairly when students are not in the room.

Item Value
Example length of an online oral exam 15 to 20 minutes, one-on-one on Zoom
Proactive extra time on assessments 100% additional time when possible
Most common extra-time accommodations 50% to 100%
Answer options in a multiple-choice question Four: one key and three distractors
Suggested reading level for question wording Grade 10

These figures come from the Lafayette College teaching centre and the Fleming College design team. Guidance like this can change, so check the sources before you rely on the numbers.

Start with what students need to show

Plan an online assessment the way you would plan a face-to-face one. Ask what students need to know or be able to do, then ask what would be the best evidence of their progress, as the University of Nebraska-Lincoln teaching centre suggests. The format comes after that answer, not before.

Course goals often say students will “understand” something, which does not tell you what to assess. A well-written learning objective has three key components, according to the same Nebraska guidance:

  • Performance: what students will do.
  • Conditions: the circumstances under which they will do it.
  • Criteria: how their work will be judged.

Then match the format to the verb. A case study suits measuring whether students can apply skills to a new situation, while a multiple-choice exam is better for testing understanding of concepts, says Duke’s teaching centre.

Which online assessment methods work best?

No single method wins; a mix does. The York University teaching hub describes three common approaches, and each answers a different question:

  • Assessment for learning happens throughout the course and gives ongoing feedback, for example quizzes, journals and labs.
  • Assessment of learning happens at key times and measures work against course outcomes, for example midterms, exams and term projects.
  • Assessment as learning engages students beyond testing, for example reflections, peer feedback and self-evaluation.

A practical rule from the Lafayette College guidance is to use more formative, low-stakes assessments than high-stakes ones. It points to literature saying formative assessments are more impactful for student learning than summative ones. Examples include ungraded Moodle quizzes, polls and peer feedback on drafts.

Short, regular checks also keep students involved, and the guide on how to engage students online covers that side in more depth.

You can go further. The UNM Center for Teaching Excellence guide suggests that smaller, frequent and sequential formative assessments can replace summative ones altogether, which may ease testing anxiety.

Authentic tasks and portfolios

An assignment is authentic if it resembles what a person might do in the real world with the knowledge and skills you teach, according to Nebraska’s guide. The same page notes that many multiple-choice exams tend to be relatively inauthentic.

The Lafayette guidance lists these authentic formats:

  • Podcasts
  • Student portfolios
  • Op-eds and letters to the editor
  • Blogs and wikis
  • Brochures and infographics
  • Presentations to stakeholders

It adds that their originality makes them less vulnerable to academic integrity issues, and that they can typically be submitted or viewed digitally.

The UNM guide suggests replacing a final exam with a portfolio of work from throughout the semester. Students collect examples from quizzes, problem sets or discussions, and can add reflections on how they used the skills. You can also layer tasks so that one product feeds the next, as in this UNM example:

  1. Students produce an annotated bibliography.
  2. They submit an introductory paragraph and hypothesis to a discussion board for peer evaluation.
  3. They use both documents to complete a final paper.

Each step gives students something useful and gives you evidence of their thinking along the way.

online assessment methods Writing notes
A seated person holds a notebook and writes with a pen.

Open-book, oral and multiple-choice formats

If you prefer a traditional high-stakes exam, the Lafayette College guidance suggests making it open-book, open-notes and open-internet. This works better when objectives sit above simple recall, and a major advantage is that it can reduce student anxiety over testing. The main disadvantage is concern about unethical behaviour, so the guidance recommends these design choices:

  • Use primarily open-ended questions rather than multiple choice.
  • Make questions highly contextualised so students apply knowledge in new situations.
  • Ask students to justify all of their answers.
  • Narrow the timeframe and scramble question order at random.

For smaller classes, oral exams are another option. The same guidance says they can be scheduled as one-on-one Zoom sessions of, for example, 15 to 20 minutes, with students admitted from the waiting room and sessions recorded for later review. Create an answer key or rubric beforehand.

The caveat is the time investment, though grading can finish as soon as the last student has been examined if the process is carefully designed. Because oral exams run live, it helps to read about synchronous vs asynchronous learning before you decide which parts of your assessment should happen at a set time.

Sometimes multiple choice is still the right tool. Fleming College says such questions are not always the most authentic assessment, but sometimes they are necessary. For a defensible question it recommends four answer options, one key and three plausible distractors, and wording aimed at a grade 10 reading level.

How can you keep online assessment fair?

Use a rubric whenever you can. Duke’s teaching centre reports that research suggests rubrics lead to more attention to detail and fewer misunderstandings in submitted work. Fleming College describes a rubric as a scoring guide and feedback tool that sets out criteria and standards.

Consider adding extra time up front. Fleming College notes that the most common additional-time accommodations are typically 50% to 100%, and recommends adding 100% additional time when possible, or unlimited time, and telling students you have done so (Fleming College).

Check your wording and format too. Duke asks whether questions are phrased so that all students, including non-native English speakers, can be successful, and whether assessments meet basic accessibility standards for visual or hearing needs.

On cheating, the evidence is calmer than the worry. The UNM guide says research suggests cheating is no more prevalent online than face-to-face, though students did report using online or personal resources during exams. Cheating becomes appealing when answers to a high-stakes task can be found by searching, so real-world application tasks are the better safeguard.

Finally, talk about expectations. The York teaching hub says speaking regularly with students clarifies expectations and supports academic honesty, and Duke advises including a statement about cheating and plagiarism in your syllabus.

Frequently asked questions

Is cheating really worse in online courses?

Show answer

Not according to the research cited in the UNM guide, which suggests cheating is no more prevalent online than in face-to-face settings. Designing tasks that apply course ideas to real situations is its recommended safeguard.

Can I copy my in-person exam into an online format?

Show answer

The UNM guide says it is generally not a good idea to duplicate a face-to-face assignment online without first considering strategies for teaching and assessing online. Choose methods that give the best evidence of your learning objectives.

How long should an online oral exam be?

Show answer

The Lafayette College guidance gives 15 to 20 minutes as an example for one-on-one Zoom sessions. Prepare an answer key or rubric in advance.

Should I give students extra time?

Show answer

Fleming College recommends adding 100% additional time to assessments when possible, or unlimited time, and making sure students know. It notes that doing this proactively can reduce the effort of arranging individual accommodations. See the Fleming College page for details.

Do I need fewer big exams online?

Show answer

The Lafayette guidance recommends more formative, low-stakes assessments than high-stakes ones. If you keep a comprehensive test, it suggests a pedagogical rationale and several smaller quizzes beforehand.