Peer Observation Done Well, Even Remotely

peer observation for teachers

Worried that peer observation for teachers means being judged? It doesn’t have to. Agree the purpose, meet before and after, and watch a real lesson or a finished online unit. That works in a room or remotely.

This page is part of the wider topic of teacher professional development, where observation sits next to other ways of growing your practice.

Item Value
Steps in a collaborative peer observation 3 steps (pre-observation conference, visit, post-observation follow-up)
Purposes of peer review of teaching 2 purposes (formative and summative)
Observation models in the Toronto guide 3 models
Minimum online unit to observe (Texas State form) 1 completed module or unit
Year of the Toronto guide 2017

These figures come from the University of Toronto peer observation guide and the Texas State asynchronous observation form. Guidance can change, so check the sources before you rely on them.

What peer observation is, and what it is not

Peer observation is one part of a wider idea called peer review of teaching. The University of Toronto guide quotes Chism (2007), who describes it as “informed colleague judgment about faculty teaching for either fostering improvement or making personnel decisions” (Toronto guide).

The same guide says peer review is used for both summative and formative purposes. A summative review gathers information to evaluate teaching for human resource decisions such as tenure and promotion (Toronto guide).

A formative review is the kind most teachers are after. It gives you specific feedback that you can use to improve your teaching practice, and it is the version the rest of this page focuses on.

Both sources come from universities and were written with faculty in mind. The steps are simple enough to adapt to a school, a training team or an online course, as long as you keep the purpose clear.

The three steps of a collaborative observation

The Toronto guide describes three steps for collaborative peer observation: a pre-observation conference, an in-person classroom visit (or an online observation for online courses), and a post-observation conversation (Toronto guide).

  1. Before: meet your observer and agree what they should look at. Name one or two questions you want answered, so the feedback is about your goals rather than their preferences.
  2. During: the guide says detailed observations of your practice, including the classroom environment and student interactions, are captured via a template or rubric and through narrative notes.
  3. After: talk it through soon afterwards, while the lesson is fresh. Start with your own view of how it went, then compare it with what the observer saw.

The guide’s contents also list a narrative log and a self-assessment among its effective practices. For recording, it offers an open-ended form and a checklist (criterion-based) form, so you can choose between free notes and fixed criteria.

How do you choose an observer and a format?

The guide has a section on choosing an observer, and the answer is rarely “your line manager”. Pick a colleague you trust, ideally someone who will ask questions rather than hand down verdicts.

The guide’s sample protocols show the range of formats available:

  • One-to-one classroom observation, where a single colleague visits.
  • Teaching squares or triads, where small groups of colleagues observe one another.
  • Peer observation of online courses, where the observer reviews the course space itself.

A pair is easiest to schedule. A group spreads the load and lets you see several teaching styles, which can be useful if you are the only person in your subject.

Observing remotely: live sessions and online courses

The Toronto guide treats online observation as an emerging context and gives it its own section. For asynchronous courses, the Texas State form gives a clear template: the observer meets the instructor for an overview of the course and objectives, then reviews the learning objectives (Texas State form).

Because nobody is “in the room”, the form has the observer look at a finished unit instead. It asks them to observe a minimum of one completed online module or unit, one that students have completed and for which the instructor has already given feedback (Texas State form).

From the same form, these are good prompts for a remote observer to work through:

  • Organisation: course materials are organised into modules that make logical sense to students.
  • Climate: the instructor has established course norms that foster a positive and inclusive environment.
  • Communication: instructions for all assignments and activities are clear and complete.
  • Accessibility: transcripts and/or captions are provided for all auditory media, including audio and video.
  • Active learning: the module includes at least one active-learning exercise to apply course content.
  • Feedback: students receive constructive and encouraging feedback on how to improve.
peer observation for teachers Group discussion
Several people sit around a low table with papers and cups.

Turning observation notes into growth

The Toronto guide quotes Chism’s view that formative assessment of teaching is “the basis for the development of effective teaching throughout one’s career” (Toronto guide). That only happens if the notes lead to something you actually change.

Try a short routine after the follow-up conversation:

  • Write down the one or two points that surprised you.
  • Choose a single change to try in your next lesson or module.
  • Ask your observer to look again later, focusing only on that change.

Your written notes also feed naturally into teacher reflection practice, where you can look for patterns across several observations. If you are building evidence for a short course or badge, the observation record may also be useful for microcredentials for teachers, depending on what the awarding body accepts.

Frequently asked questions

Is peer observation the same as being evaluated?

Show answer

Not necessarily. The Toronto guide separates formative review, which gives you feedback to improve, from summative review, which supports decisions such as tenure and promotion (Toronto guide). Agree which one you are doing before anyone watches.

Can you do peer observation if you only teach online?

Show answer

Yes. The Texas State form is designed for asynchronous online courses and has the observer review a completed module or unit rather than a live class (Texas State form).

What should the observer record?

Show answer

That depends on your goals. The Toronto guide offers narrative logs, open-ended forms and checklist forms, so you can choose free notes, fixed criteria or a mix (Toronto guide).

Do you need a formal template?

Show answer

No, but a simple one helps the observer stay on your questions. The Texas State form is a ready-made example for online units if you want to adapt something rather than start from scratch.