You teach all day, and reflecting on it is the first thing to slip. Teacher reflection practice works best as a short routine: after a lesson, note what happened, why it mattered and one change you will try.
This guide sits within the wider topic of teacher professional development, where reflection is one habit among many.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Borton’s basic reflection model | 3 questions: What? So what? Now what? (1970) |
| Gibbs’ Reflective Cycle | 6 stages |
| Brookfield’s critical lenses | 4 lenses |
| Bain’s reflection framework | 5 Rs (2002) |
| Schön’s kinds of reflection | 2 kinds (1983) |
These figures come from the MacPherson Institute guide to reflective teaching and a Structural Learning article on reflective practice. Models and details can change, so check the sources before you rely on them.
What reflection actually asks of you
Reflection is more than replaying a lesson in your head on the drive home. The NSW Department of Education notes that effective teachers continually reflect on and improve what they do, but that reflection is not a natural process for all teachers, as its reflective practice page explains.
The same page quotes Biggs (2003): learning new techniques is like the fish that provides a meal for today, while reflective practice is the net that provides the meal for the rest of one’s life. In other words, a toolkit of tricks helps, but the habit of examining your own teaching is what keeps you improving.
Brookfield (2017) describes critical reflection as the sustained and intentional process of identifying and checking the accuracy and validity of your teaching assumptions, as set out in a self-study from Asia Pacific University. That is a useful test for any routine you build: does it make you check what you assumed?
Two moments to reflect
Schön (1983) named two kinds of reflection, according to the Structural Learning article. Reflection-in-action happens while you are teaching, such as rephrasing a question that fell flat.
Reflection-on-action happens after the lesson, when you look back over your notes, your memory or a colleague’s feedback. The routine below is built for that second moment.
Which model should you start with?
There are many models, and the MacPherson Institute points out that you may need a different approach depending on your goal. Sometimes you will want no model at all and a free-form approach instead.
Here are the main options for after-lesson reflection:
- Borton: a simple, practical framework based on the 1970 model of “What? So what? Now what?”, usable in formal or informal settings.
- Boud: a triangle of Experience, Reflection, Learning, which is less prescriptive.
- Gibbs: a more structured cycle from Experience through Feelings, Evaluation, Analysis and Conclusion to an Action Plan.
- Kolb: a cycle that moves from Experience through Reflective Observation and Abstract Conceptualization to Active Experimentation.
Gibbs puts more weight on feelings, which matters when a topic or activity is contentious or emotional. If you want something lighter, Borton’s three questions are the easiest place to begin.
A simple routine you can run after any lesson
This routine borrows Borton’s three questions and adds a short check-back. It is a suggested layout, not a requirement from any one source.
- What? Describe what happened in plain lines: what students did, what you noticed, and what worked and what did not.
- So what? Ask why it happened, how you felt, and whether it fits a wider pattern you have seen before.
- Now what? Choose a single change for the next lesson and write it so you can test it. Structural Learning advises spending at least two minutes per entry on “what would I do differently”.
- Check back. At the start of your next reflection, note whether the change helped.
The MacPherson Institute gives an example of a teacher, Maya, who set aside time to keep a log after each class and found it helpful to consider what worked well. Keeping the entry short and in the same place makes it easier to repeat.

Looking beyond your own view
Your own memory of a lesson is only one angle. Brookfield (2005) suggests viewing your teaching through four lenses, as the Oxford Brookes open resource lists them:
- your own autobiography as a teacher and learner;
- your students’ eyes;
- your colleagues’ experiences;
- educational literature.
The colleagues’ lens includes peer observation and discussion. Inviting someone into your room is one way to use it, and peer observation for teachers is a useful next read if you want to set up such a visit.
Reflection also pairs well with formal study. If you are working towards an online teaching certificate, a short lesson log is a handy habit to build alongside your coursework.
Why reflection logs stall, and how to fix them
Structural Learning reports that reflection logs kept as a formality stay at description. The reflections that change practice are the ones that name a single, testable adjustment (Schön, 1983).
Its guidance is that open-ended journalling produces description, while question-driven prompts produce analysis. If your notes read like a diary, add the “So what?” and “Now what?” questions and see whether the entries change.
- Keep one change per entry rather than a long list of intentions.
- Write about what students did, not only how the lesson felt.
- Return to last time’s change before writing a new one.
Frequently asked questions
How long should a reflection take?
Show answer
The sources do not set a fixed length. Structural Learning advises spending at least two minutes per entry on what you would do differently, so a short, regular entry is enough to start.
Do I need to follow a named model?
Show answer
No. The MacPherson Institute says there may be times when you do not need any model and want to approach reflection in a free-form manner. A model helps most when your notes keep drifting.
What is the difference between reflection-in-action and reflection-on-action?
Show answer
Reflection-in-action happens during a lesson, while reflection-on-action happens afterwards. Schön (1983) named both, and the routine in this guide supports the second.
Why does my reflection journal feel like a diary?
Show answer
Open-ended journalling tends to produce description. Adding question-driven prompts, such as “So what?” and “Now what?”, pushes entries towards analysis and a concrete next step.



